Best Selling Anal Toys | Top Plugs, Beads & Prostate Massagers

Best Selling Anal Toys

Our Anal Toys Best Sellers collection brings together the most popular picks customers love. Browse bestselling plugs, beads, probes, and prostate massagers—designed to deliver intense sensations with a comfortable, body-safe feel.

 

Filter

Sort by
Quaker Anal Vibe - Into You IndigoQuaker Anal Vibe - Into You Indigo
-13%
Vendor: VeDOQuaker Anal Vibe - Into You Indigo
Regular price $37.99 Sale price$32.99
Bubbles Bumpy Starter Anal Plug - PinkBubbles Bumpy Starter Anal Plug - Pink
Vendor: XR Brands Trinity VibesBubbles Bumpy Starter Anal Plug - Pink
Sale price$13.13
Anal Adventures - Easy Plug - BlackAnal Adventures - Easy Plug - Black
-7%
Vendor: Blush NoveltiesAnal Adventures - Easy Plug - Black
Regular price $5.99 Sale price$5.59
Booty Bling Metal Heart Plug - Small - PinkBooty Bling Metal Heart Plug - Small - Pink
Vendor: Doc JohnsonBooty Bling Metal Heart Plug - Small - Pink
Sale price$15.91
Cheeky Charms - Silver Metal Butt Plug - Heart - Clear - MediumCheeky Charms - Silver Metal Butt Plug - Heart - Clear - Medium
-10%
Vendor: VibenCheeky Charms - Silver Metal Butt Plug - Heart - Clear - Medium
Regular price $18.00 Sale price$16.20
Cheeky Charms - Silver Metal Butt Plug - Heart - Clear - SmallCheeky Charms - Silver Metal Butt Plug - Heart - Clear - Small
-11%
Vendor: VibenCheeky Charms - Silver Metal Butt Plug - Heart - Clear - Small
Regular price $16.00 Sale price$14.31
Anal Adventures - Platinum - Silicone Vibrating Prostate Massager 03 - BlackAnal Adventures - Platinum - Silicone Vibrating Prostate Massager 03 - Black
-18%
Vendor: Blush NoveltiesAnal Adventures - Platinum - Silicone Vibrating Prostate Massager 03 - Black
Regular price $36.99 Sale price$30.39
B Yours - Curvy Anal Plug - PinkB Yours - Curvy Anal Plug - Pink
-47%
Vendor: Blush NoveltiesB Yours - Curvy Anal Plug - Pink
Regular price $14.99 Sale price$7.99
Luxe - Wearable Vibra Slim Plug - Small - PurpleLuxe - Wearable Vibra Slim Plug - Small - Purple
-17%
Vendor: Blush NoveltiesLuxe - Wearable Vibra Slim Plug - Small - Purple
Regular price $24.99 Sale price$20.79
Jet - Annihilator - Carbon Metallic BlackJet - Annihilator - Carbon Metallic Black
-14%
Vendor: Blush NoveltiesJet - Annihilator - Carbon Metallic Black
Regular price $57.99 Sale price$49.59
Sassy 10 Anal Beads - PinkSassy 10 Anal Beads - Pink
-20%
Vendor: Blush NoveltiesSassy 10 Anal Beads - Pink
Regular price $7.99 Sale price$6.39
Mini Vibro Tease Slender Probe - PinkMini Vibro Tease Slender Probe - Pink
Vendor: CalExoticsMini Vibro Tease Slender Probe - Pink
Sale price$26.99
Rechargeable X-5 Power Beads - BlackRechargeable X-5 Power Beads - Black
Vendor: CalExoticsRechargeable X-5 Power Beads - Black
Sale price$29.69
Pretty Love Special Anal Stimulation - BlackPretty Love Special Anal Stimulation - Black
Vendor: Pretty LovePretty Love Special Anal Stimulation - Black
Sale price$19.44
Oh My Gem - Charm Plug - Amethyst - PurpleOh My Gem - Charm Plug - Amethyst - Purple
Vendor: BlushOh My Gem - Charm Plug - Amethyst - Purple
Sale price$50.39
Rock Bottom Rotating Probe - BlackRock Bottom Rotating Probe - Black
Vendor: CalExoticsRock Bottom Rotating Probe - Black
Sale price$46.79
Pig Hole 5 XXL Fuckable Buttplug - RedPig Hole 5 XXL Fuckable Buttplug - Red
Vendor: OxballsPig Hole 5 XXL Fuckable Buttplug - Red
Sale price$139.00
Flexible Vibrating Silicone Butt Plug - PinkFlexible Vibrating Silicone Butt Plug - Pink
Vendor: XR BrandsFlexible Vibrating Silicone Butt Plug - Pink
Sale price$31.73
Booty Bloom Silicone Rose Anal Plug - SmallBooty Bloom Silicone Rose Anal Plug - Small
Vendor: XR BrandsBooty Bloom Silicone Rose Anal Plug - Small
Sale price$34.92
Anal Adventures Matrix - Expedition Plug - Lunar BlueAnal Adventures Matrix - Expedition Plug - Lunar Blue
Vendor: BlushAnal Adventures Matrix - Expedition Plug - Lunar Blue
Sale price$34.39
Morph Hole 1 - Small - Black IceMorph Hole 1 - Small - Black Ice
Vendor: SaleMorph Hole 1 - Small - Black Ice
Sale price$76.00
Lifeforms Medium Butt Plug
-1%
Vendor: NasstoysLifeforms Medium Butt Plug
Regular price $17.60 Sale price$17.46
Southern Lights - Vibrating Light Up Anal Probe - PinkSouthern Lights - Vibrating Light Up Anal Probe - Pink
Vendor: CalExoticsSouthern Lights - Vibrating Light Up Anal Probe - Pink
Sale price$52.19
Mason Remote Control Silicone Butt Plug - BlackMason Remote Control Silicone Butt Plug - Black
Vendor: Maia ToysMason Remote Control Silicone Butt Plug - Black
Sale price$81.90
Glams Xchange Heart - Medium - BlackGlams Xchange Heart - Medium - Black
-10%
Vendor: NsnoveltiesGlams Xchange Heart - Medium - Black
Regular price $9.90 Sale price$8.91
Cheeky Charms - Gunmetal Metal Butt Plug - Round - Deep Purple - SmallCheeky Charms - Gunmetal Metal Butt Plug - Round - Deep Purple - Small
-11%
Vendor: VibenCheeky Charms - Gunmetal Metal Butt Plug - Round - Deep Purple - Small
Regular price $16.00 Sale price$14.31
Cheeky Charms - Silver Metal Butt Plug - Round - Clear - SmallCheeky Charms - Silver Metal Butt Plug - Round - Clear - Small
-10%
Vendor: VibenCheeky Charms - Silver Metal Butt Plug - Round - Clear - Small
Regular price $15.00 Sale price$13.50
Anal Adventures - Basic Anal Plug - Small - BlackAnal Adventures - Basic Anal Plug - Small - Black
-9%
Vendor: Blush NoveltiesAnal Adventures - Basic Anal Plug - Small - Black
Regular price $7.00 Sale price$6.39
21x Silicone Butt Plug With Remote - Pink21x Silicone Butt Plug With Remote - Pink
Vendor: XR Brands Bang21x Silicone Butt Plug With Remote - Pink
Sale price$62.96
Pink Gem Glass Anal Plug - Small
Vendor: XR Brands Booty SparksPink Gem Glass Anal Plug - Small
Sale price$17.47
Luxe - Beginner Plug Kit - PinkLuxe - Beginner Plug Kit - Pink
-17%
Vendor: Blush NoveltiesLuxe - Beginner Plug Kit - Pink
Regular price $27.99 Sale price$23.19
Luxe - Beginner Plug Small - PinkLuxe - Beginner Plug Small - Pink
-45%
Vendor: Blush NoveltiesLuxe - Beginner Plug Small - Pink
Regular price $15.99 Sale price$8.79
Luxe Explore - Fuchsia
-16%
Vendor: Blush NoveltiesLuxe Explore - Fuchsia
Regular price $20.99 Sale price$17.59
Dr. Joel Kaplan Compact Prostate MassagerDr. Joel Kaplan Compact Prostate Massager
-1%
Vendor: CalExoticsDr. Joel Kaplan Compact Prostate Massager
Regular price $27.99 Sale price$27.89
Dr. Joel Kaplan Premium Prostate Massager - BlackDr. Joel Kaplan Premium Prostate Massager - Black
-1%
Vendor: CalExoticsDr. Joel Kaplan Premium Prostate Massager - Black
Regular price $28.99 Sale price$28.79
Ram Anal Balloon Pump - Black
-1%
Vendor: NasstoysRam Anal Balloon Pump - Black
Regular price $24.20 Sale price$24.12
Vibrators Shopping Guide - MyPleasure
Vibrators Shopping Guide
Adult Candy & Edibles: Sweet Ways to Turn Up Pleasure - MyPleasure
Adult Candy & Edibles: Sweet Ways to Turn Up Pleasure
BDSM Basics: An Intro to BDSM That’s Safe, Sexy, and Totally Beginner-Friendly - MyPleasure
BDSM Basics: An Intro to BDSM That’s Safe, Sexy, and Totally Beginner-Friendly
A Self-Love Guide to Valentine’s Day When You’re Single - MyPleasure
A Self-Love Guide to Valentine’s Day When You’re Single
Valentine’s Day in a Long-Distance Relationship - MyPleasure
Valentine’s Day in a Long-Distance Relationship
Valentine’s 2026 Preview: Top Romantic Toys to Watch - MyPleasure
Valentine’s 2026 Preview: Top Romantic Toys to Watch