Butt Plugs Collection – Explore Silicone, Vibrating & Metal Plugs

Butt Plugs

Anal plugs are designed to be inserted and comfortably worn, providing a feeling of fullness and gentle stimulation. They are popular for both beginners and experienced users and come in various sizes, shapes, and materials.

Filter

Sort by
Cloud 9 Novelties Gems Jeweled Silicone Anal Plug - LargeCloud 9 Novelties Gems Jeweled Silicone Anal Plug - Large
Vendor: Cloud 9 NoveltiesCloud 9 Novelties Gems Jeweled Silicone Anal Plug - Large
Sale price$16.11
Cloud 9 Novelties Gems Jeweled Silicone Anal Plug - MediumCloud 9 Novelties Gems Jeweled Silicone Anal Plug - Medium
-7%
Vendor: Cloud 9 NoveltiesCloud 9 Novelties Gems Jeweled Silicone Anal Plug - Medium
Regular price $14.95 Sale price$13.88
Pink Gem Anal Plug - LargePink Gem Anal Plug - Large
Vendor: XR Brands Booty SparksPink Gem Anal Plug - Large
Sale price$24.90
Gossip Rump Rockers - VioletGossip Rump Rockers - Violet
Vendor: Curve ToysGossip Rump Rockers - Violet
Sale price$22.67
Gossip Rump Rockers - MagentaGossip Rump Rockers - Magenta
Vendor: Curve ToysGossip Rump Rockers - Magenta
Sale price$22.67
Red Heart Gem Anal Plug - SmallRed Heart Gem Anal Plug - Small
Vendor: XR Brands Booty SparksRed Heart Gem Anal Plug - Small
Sale price$16.66
Red Heart Gem Anal Plug - MediumRed Heart Gem Anal Plug - Medium
Vendor: XR Brands Booty SparksRed Heart Gem Anal Plug - Medium
Sale price$19.84
Pink Gem Anal Plug - SmallPink Gem Anal Plug - Small
Vendor: XR Brands Booty SparksPink Gem Anal Plug - Small
Sale price$14.70
Pink Gem Anal Plug - MediumPink Gem Anal Plug - Medium
Vendor: XR Brands Booty SparksPink Gem Anal Plug - Medium
Sale price$18.35
Luxe - Beginner Plug Kit - BlackLuxe - Beginner Plug Kit - Black
-17%
Vendor: Blush NoveltiesLuxe - Beginner Plug Kit - Black
Regular price $27.99 Sale price$23.19
Luxe - Beginner Plug Kit - PinkLuxe - Beginner Plug Kit - Pink
-17%
Vendor: Blush NoveltiesLuxe - Beginner Plug Kit - Pink
Regular price $27.99 Sale price$23.19
Anal Fantasy Elite Vibrating Ass FuckerAnal Fantasy Elite Vibrating Ass Fucker
Vendor: PipedreamAnal Fantasy Elite Vibrating Ass Fucker
Sale price$96.99
Luxe - Beginner Plug Small - PinkLuxe - Beginner Plug Small - Pink
-45%
Vendor: Blush NoveltiesLuxe - Beginner Plug Small - Pink
Regular price $15.99 Sale price$8.79
Red Rose Anal Plug - MediumRed Rose Anal Plug - Medium
Vendor: XR Brands Booty SparksRed Rose Anal Plug - Medium
Sale price$18.35
Clear Gem Anal Plug - MediumClear Gem Anal Plug - Medium
Vendor: XR Brands Booty SparksClear Gem Anal Plug - Medium
Sale price$18.35
White Fox Tail Anal Plug and Ears Set
Vendor: XR Brands TailzWhite Fox Tail Anal Plug and Ears Set
Sale price$61.19
Aria Vibrating Silicone Anal Plug - SmallAria Vibrating Silicone Anal Plug - Small
Vendor: XR Brands Trinity VibesAria Vibrating Silicone Anal Plug - Small
Sale price$34.09
Booty Bling - Wearable Silicone Beads - PurpleBooty Bling - Wearable Silicone Beads - Purple
Vendor: Doc JohnsonBooty Bling - Wearable Silicone Beads - Purple
Sale price$30.14
Anal Fantasy Elite Ultimate P-Spot MilkerAnal Fantasy Elite Ultimate P-Spot Milker
Vendor: PipedreamAnal Fantasy Elite Ultimate P-Spot Milker
Sale price$109.99
Temptasia - Bling Plug - Medium - BlackTemptasia - Bling Plug - Medium - Black
-37%
Vendor: Blush NoveltiesTemptasia - Bling Plug - Medium - Black
Regular price $23.99 Sale price$15.19
Luxe - Bling Plugs Training Kit - Pink With White Gems
-24%
Vendor: Blush NoveltiesLuxe - Bling Plugs Training Kit - Pink With White Gems
Regular price $47.30 Sale price$35.99
Jet - Annihilator - Carbon Metallic BlackJet - Annihilator - Carbon Metallic Black
-14%
Vendor: Blush NoveltiesJet - Annihilator - Carbon Metallic Black
Regular price $57.99 Sale price$49.59
Jet - Bruiser - Carbon Metallic BlackJet - Bruiser - Carbon Metallic Black
-17%
Vendor: Blush NoveltiesJet - Bruiser - Carbon Metallic Black
Regular price $25.99 Sale price$21.59
Jet - Black Jack - Carbon Metallic BlackJet - Black Jack - Carbon Metallic Black
-17%
Vendor: Blush NoveltiesJet - Black Jack - Carbon Metallic Black
Regular price $23.99 Sale price$19.99
Jet Large Plug - Carbon Metallic BlackJet Large Plug - Carbon Metallic Black
-33%
Vendor: Blush NoveltiesJet Large Plug - Carbon Metallic Black
Regular price $18.99 Sale price$12.79
The 9's the Silver Starter Bejeweled Stainless Steel Plug - PinkThe 9's the Silver Starter Bejeweled Stainless Steel Plug - Pink
Vendor: Icon BrandsThe 9's the Silver Starter Bejeweled Stainless Steel Plug - Pink
Sale price$14.95
Firefly Pleasure Plug - Medium - BlueFirefly Pleasure Plug - Medium - Blue
-9%
Vendor: NsnoveltiesFirefly Pleasure Plug - Medium - Blue
Regular price $16.50 Sale price$15.03
Firefly Pleasure Plug - Medium - PinkFirefly Pleasure Plug - Medium - Pink
-9%
Vendor: NsnoveltiesFirefly Pleasure Plug - Medium - Pink
Regular price $16.50 Sale price$15.03
Fox Tail Anal PlugFox Tail Anal Plug
Vendor: XR Brands TailzFox Tail Anal Plug
Sale price$46.44
Grey Fox Tail Anal PlugGrey Fox Tail Anal Plug
-4%
Vendor: XR Brands TailzGrey Fox Tail Anal Plug
Regular price $54.44 Sale price$52.43
Expandable Butt PlugExpandable Butt Plug
Vendor: CalExoticsExpandable Butt Plug
Sale price$32.39
Anal Trainer KitAnal Trainer Kit
Vendor: CalExoticsAnal Trainer Kit
Sale price$35.99
Booty Bling - Purple - SmallBooty Bling - Purple - Small
-10%
Vendor: Doc JohnsonBooty Bling - Purple - Small
Regular price $27.60 Sale price$24.84
Booty Bling - Silver - SmallBooty Bling - Silver - Small
-10%
Vendor: Doc JohnsonBooty Bling - Silver - Small
Regular price $27.60 Sale price$24.84
Vac-U-Lock Large Black Suction Cup Plug
-10%
Vendor: Doc JohnsonVac-U-Lock Large Black Suction Cup Plug
Regular price $23.40 Sale price$21.06
Spark Ignition Prv-02 - Carbon Fiber
-24%
Vendor: Blush NoveltiesSpark Ignition Prv-02 - Carbon Fiber
Regular price $48.40 Sale price$36.79
B Yours Eclipse Pleaser - Medium - PurpleB Yours Eclipse Pleaser - Medium - Purple
-20%
Vendor: Blush NoveltiesB Yours Eclipse Pleaser - Medium - Purple
Regular price $9.99 Sale price$7.99
B Yours Eclipse Pleaser - Medium - PinkB Yours Eclipse Pleaser - Medium - Pink
-20%
Vendor: Blush NoveltiesB Yours Eclipse Pleaser - Medium - Pink
Regular price $9.99 Sale price$7.99
B Yours Eclipse Pleaser - Small - PurpleB Yours Eclipse Pleaser - Small - Purple
-47%
Vendor: Blush NoveltiesB Yours Eclipse Pleaser - Small - Purple
Regular price $14.99 Sale price$7.99
Titanmen Anal Stretcher 6 Inch PlugTitanmen Anal Stretcher 6 Inch Plug
-10%
Vendor: Doc JohnsonTitanmen Anal Stretcher 6 Inch Plug
Regular price $25.70 Sale price$23.13
Luxe Discover - Black
-17%
Vendor: Blush NoveltiesLuxe Discover - Black
Regular price $29.99 Sale price$24.79
Luxe Little Thumper - Black
-18%
Vendor: Blush NoveltiesLuxe Little Thumper - Black
Regular price $31.99 Sale price$26.39
Luxe Little Thumper - Pink
-18%
Vendor: Blush NoveltiesLuxe Little Thumper - Pink
Regular price $31.99 Sale price$26.39
Luxe Discover - Pink
-17%
Vendor: Blush NoveltiesLuxe Discover - Pink
Regular price $29.99 Sale price$24.79
Vibrators Shopping Guide - MyPleasure
Vibrators Shopping Guide
Adult Candy & Edibles: Sweet Ways to Turn Up Pleasure - MyPleasure
Adult Candy & Edibles: Sweet Ways to Turn Up Pleasure
BDSM Basics: An Intro to BDSM That’s Safe, Sexy, and Totally Beginner-Friendly - MyPleasure
BDSM Basics: An Intro to BDSM That’s Safe, Sexy, and Totally Beginner-Friendly
A Self-Love Guide to Valentine’s Day When You’re Single - MyPleasure
A Self-Love Guide to Valentine’s Day When You’re Single
Valentine’s Day in a Long-Distance Relationship - MyPleasure
Valentine’s Day in a Long-Distance Relationship
Valentine’s 2026 Preview: Top Romantic Toys to Watch - MyPleasure
Valentine’s 2026 Preview: Top Romantic Toys to Watch